Indianapolis restaurant with Philadelphia-style hoagies is a big hit

Born and lifted in Pottstown, Kristina Mazza has invested the past 7 yrs teaching Indianapolis the phrase “hoagie.”

The Penn Point out alum relocated to Indiana 15 many years in the past, following in the footsteps of her mom and dad, who manufactured the very same shift. Just after quite a few years running an Indianapolis cafe team, Mazza resolved to start her personal venture. Enter Hoagies & Hops, which aims to give Hoosiers an reliable style of Pennsylvania and the Philly region.

“I missed the food items,” Mazza informed Billy Penn, describing her inspiration. “And I knew that there had to be other people like myself, and my husband, and my mothers and fathers.”

The restaurant, which shares house with the tap place of Chilly Water Brewing Corporation, has a decor that blends Pennsylvania and Indiana pride. On its walls cling memorabilia repping the Phillies, Sixers, Eagles, and Flyers — as well as Penn Point out, Villanova, and Temple — suitable together with shoutouts to Indiana universities and teams.

There’s also a Liscio’s-branded clock, Dietz & Watson umbrellas shading outdoor tables, a Will Smith poster, and a cardboard cutout of Rocky.

The restaurant brings a sliver of the Keystone State’s distinct food tradition to the Midwest — providing a novel practical experience to persons who’ve never built the 600-mile journey eastward, though also supplying East Coastline transplants a flavor of household.

Mazza isn’t on your own in her endeavor to carry a flavor of the Philly area in other places. A lot of expats have introduced southeastern Pennsylvania’s regional delicacies to other towns, landing in all places from the West Coastline to New England to OG England.

Connecticut is now household to two places of Philly’s: A Flavor of Philadelphia, 1 in Norwich that’s been close to for a ten years and a just-opened sibling in New Haven. They’re operated by Shem Adams, who was born and lifted in Southwest Philly and moved north about 20 a long time in the past.

For Adams, Philly food stuff was something he did not understand was distinctive until eventually he lived in other places. “Whether it is the bread, the seasoning, or simply the brotherly like,” Adams told Billy Penn, “it’s just various.”


💌 Love Philly? Indicator up for the cost-free Billy Penn e-newsletter to get every little thing you need to have to know about Philadelphia, each working day.


At times, individuals distinctions signify that a bit of translation has to transpire for locals to have an understanding of his menu. For illustration, Adams sells h2o ice, which he mentioned has prompted bewildered clients to ask, “Are you charging THAT for ice drinking water?”

Andrew Ahn, who was born in New Jersey and grew up in Olney and the Philly suburbs, opened Boo’s Philly Cheesesteaks and Hoagies in Los Angeles a minimal about 10 a long time ago. Hoagies and cheesesteaks were being “staples” for his family when he was growing up, Ahn stated, and he ate them about after a week.

He moved out to LA to function on movie initiatives two decades ago, he mentioned — but when his mothers and fathers moved out far too, they complained they could not obtain a excellent cheesesteak. Consequently, Boo’s was born.

“It was not like we experienced any genuine intent to provide cheesesteaks or hoagies out here,” Ahn mentioned. “It was additional of a necessity.”

The interior pays homage to Philly sports teams and icons
Asha Prihar / Billy Penn

All about the bread (and the oil, and the meat, and the cheese, and…)

As its identify suggests, Hoagies & Hops’ menu has a great deal of the signature sandwiches, but also an array of Philly and Pennsylvania Dutch food items. There are Herr’s potato chips, pickled red beet eggs, Hank’s Gourmand Beverages, and yes, cheesesteaks. You are going to also discover some additional artistic things, like warm puppies topped with cheesesteak components (reminiscent of the frankfurters at Pat’s King of Steaks) or wrapped in Seltzer’s Lebanon bologna and Muenster cheese.

It’s mainly a blend of the regional cuisine Mazza grew up with at corner suppliers and farmer’s marketplaces, along with her family’s Pa. Dutch recipes. But it all started with her appreciate for hoagies.

Mazza started out by partnering with the owners of a regional brewery who ended up looking for a dependable meals seller. She crafted a hoagie menu with things named soon after locations and issues in Philly and Pennsylvania that meant some thing to her, and performed all-around with a residence oil recipe until eventually she perfected the taste and texture.

She also created absolutely sure to source components from the first place. The most essential factor, Mazza said, is the bread — Liscio’s rolls delivered in from South Jersey. (The brand won out in a aspect-by-side taste take a look at.)

“That’s the quantity 1 component,” Mazza explained. “If I couldn’t get the rolls, there would be no uniqueness.”

The end result was a menu with sandwiches like the “Hog Island” (salami, ham, prosciutto, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onion, oil), the “Dutch Country” (Lebanon bologna, Muenster, total grain beer mustard, lettuce, tomatoes), and the “Reading Terminal” (Italian marinated tomatoes, banana peppers, parmesan, provolone, lettuce, onion, oil).

Element of owning these types of offerings has meant receiving folks to have an understanding of what differentiates a hoagie from the subs or sandwiches people today in the place are used to.

“There’s undoubtedly a large amount to train men and women,” Mazza stated. “A hoagie need to be on an Italian roll, not a French roll. A whole lot of people will however do French rolls of sorts.”

In the course of her initial 12 months serving hoagies, Mazza found that people in Indiana are not substantial admirers of chilly sandwiches, so men and women just retained requesting “Phillys” — a time period for cheesesteaks Mazza experienced in no way listened to right before given that it is typically utilised outside the Philadelphia region. (“What really should I have, like Mike Schmidt and the workforce?” she stated.)

Hoagies & Hops opened in Indianapolis in 2015
Asha Prihar / Billy Penn

Perfecting cheesesteaks and looking for gentle pretzels

Cheesesteaks ended up by no means Mazza’s private go-to again household, but when she did incorporate them to the menu, she preferred to make sure she did them ideal.

She took a vacation to Philadelphia to refresh her memory, being with a close friend in Fishtown. She frequented at the very least six distinct places, and — involving cheesesteaks and rooster cheesesteaks — tried out close to 14 or 15 kinds, she said. From there, she determined which design was her beloved: “mixing every little thing, since that way you get the identical bites.”

She also determined she’d only provide kinds of cheeses typically provided in Philly — American, provolone, and whiz — not like chain dining places like Penn Station or Subway, which also supply choices like pepper jack or Swiss. (Penn Station is an Ohio-based chain that models itself as specializing in “East Coastline subs.”)

“I don’t want any person to place that on cheesesteak,” Mazza stated, “because when you’re out in Philly and in the burbs, you are not receiving Swiss, mozzarella … I’m only gonna offer you what is genuine.”

The Hoagies & Hops menu is still matter to evolution. The cafe made use of to offer gentle pretzels, but Mazza has also been owning trouble obtaining a new bulk provider considering that Indianapolis-based mostly Pat’s Philly Pretzels went out of company through the pandemic.

They also operate specials from time to time, Mazza claimed, like serving frizzled steak on prime of a breaded pork tenderloin to generate a entertaining Philly/Indiana crossover dish.

A pending addition to the repertoire is roast pork sandwiches. Figuring out how to do it ideal has been a method of demo and error, Mazza mentioned.

The shop made a stable result fairly a short while ago — after Mazza traveled out to Philly a few weeks ago with Hoagies & Hops general supervisor Donnie Begley and watched DiNic’s make the sandwiches at Looking at Terminal Market place. Discovering a steady supply of sharp provolone has been the holdup, for each Mazza.

“That’s something we’d really like to place on the menu,” she reported. “It’s just nonetheless attempting to determine out … logistics.”

Getting your persons by way of food stuff

When shoppers from Philadelphia to start with pay a visit to Philly’s in Connecticut, they can be a very little skeptical, mentioned Adams, the proprietor. He likes to “warm them up by showing them the Amoroso luggage or us slicing fresh new ribeye on the location,” and they normally can tell he’s the authentic offer soon after a discussion with him, he said.

For Ahn, who operates Boo’s in Los Angeles, the whole goal of his procedure is to produce “comfort food” that is Philly completed ideal.

“We’re not fancy, we’re not bougie, we’re not trying to be some thing that we’re not,” Ahn stated. “We’re just undertaking matters the way it should be performed, which is basic, tasty, to the position. Just reliable and true, y’know?”

Ahead of she commenced Hoagies & Hops in Indianapolis, Mazza didn’t genuinely know other individuals there who have been from the Philadelphia area, or even from the East Coastline. But the moment she established up shop, “they all came out of the woodwork,” she stated.

Now that expats gravitate towards her cafe, Mazza loves to interact. She often sparks social media debates in excess of Sheetz vs. Wawa, or the finest sites to go at the Jersey Shore. And Hoagies & Hops encourages clients to come in to enjoy Philly sports activities, at times even featuring discounts to men and women dressed in ideal staff colors.

“When I have the Eagles online games [on], I love when persons appear in listed here, and they are all sporting their Eagles gear, and they start chatting,” Mazza stated.

Sometimes, skeptics from western Pa. quit by and can be “very judgmental” ahead of they even consider the food, Mazza said, but she just shrugs them off. “I necessarily mean, I have been open up for 7 decades for a purpose.”

After all that time, she’s continue to meeting new folks who hail from her household region and get psyched about what the restaurant has to provide.

“I’ve achieved folks who’ve been in this article for four yrs, I have fulfilled people who’ve been listed here for say, considerably less than a thirty day period,” Mazza claimed. Folks “just preserve acquiring out.”